Vijñāna Bhairava Tantra · Part III — The One Hundred and Twelve Dhāraṇās (Verses 24⁠–⁠138)

Dhāraṇā 71 — ‘There is no mind or inner faculty in me’

Open in the interactive reader

चित्ताद्यन्तःकृतिर्नास्ति ममान्तर्भावयेदिति । विकल्पानामभावेन विकल्पैरुज्झितो भवेत् ॥ ९४ ॥
cittādy-antaḥ-kṛtir nāsti mamāntar bhāvayed iti | vikalpānām abhāvena vikalpair ujjhito bhavet || 94 ||
PhoneticLine 1: chit-taady-an-tah-kri-tir | naas-ti | ma-maan-tar | bhaa-va-yed | i-ti Line 2: vi-kal-paa-naam | a-bhaa-ve-na | vi-kal-pair | uj-jhi-to | bha-vet
“One should contemplate: ‘In me there is no inner faculty such as mind.’ Through the absence of thought-constructs, one becomes free from thought-constructs.”

Explanation

Dhāraṇā 71 is a practice of self-inquiry through negation. The meditator contemplates that within him there is no citta, no mind, no inner faculty (antaḥkaraṇa). By this contemplation, thought-constructs lose their basis and one becomes free from them. For the seeker, the verse uses a purified thought to dismantle the very instrument of thought.

Detailed Explanation

1. चित्ताद्यन्तःकृतिर्नास्ति ममान्तर्भावयेदिति (cittādy-antaḥ-kṛtir nāsti mamāntar bhāvayed iti):

“One should contemplate: ‘In me there is no inner faculty such as mind.’”

  • चित्ताद्यन्तःकृतिः (cittādyantaḥkṛtiḥ) (cpd.; antaḥkṛti ← √kṛ; nom. sg. f.): The inner faculty, mind and the rest; citta + ādi + antaḥ-kṛti (“inner instrument” = antaḥkaraṇa).
  • न अस्ति (na asti) (na + asti ← √as, 2P; pres. 3sg.): Is not; नास्ति.
  • मम (mama) (gen. sg. of aham): Of me, in me.
  • अन्तः (antaḥ) (indecl.): Inner — within.
  • भावयेत् (bhāvayet) (√bhū, 1P, caus.; opt. 3sg.): Should contemplate.
  • इति (iti) (indecl.): Thus.

Interpretation (elaborative): The antaḥkaraṇa, the inner instrument, consists in Sāṅkhya and Vedānta of manas (mind), buddhi (intellect), ahaṃkāra (ego) and sometimes citta (memory-store). These are the faculties through which we think, decide, identify and remember. The contemplation is cittādy-antaḥkṛtir nāsti mama: "in me there is no inner faculty such as mind". This is a radical negation: one denies not only external objects but the very instruments of experience. Kṣemarāja explains that this is a śuddha vikalpa, a purified thought: it uses a thought to cut through thought, like a thorn used to remove a thorn. By contemplating "I have no mind", the identification with the mind is loosened. The Upaniṣadic method of neti neti and Ramana Maharshi's self-inquiry ("I am not the body, I am not the mind") work similarly. For the practitioner: sit quietly and reflect, "I am not the mind; there is no mind in me". Do not argue with yourself; let the thought sink in. Notice what remains when the mind is negated: awareness, which is aware of the negation itself. Cittādy-antaḥ-kṛtir nāsti mamāntaḥ, "there is no mind or inner faculty within me", is a negation to be contemplated (bhāvayed iti). The inner faculties (antaḥkaraṇa) are manas (mind), buddhi (intellect) and ahaṃkāra (ego). Śivopādhyāya explains that the practitioner repeatedly affirms that these are not his true self: "I am not the mind, not the intellect, not the ego." This is similar to the neti neti ("not this, not this") of the Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad and to Śaṅkara's Nirvāṇaṣaṭkam, which begins "I am not the mind, intellect, ego or memory". Kṣemarāja notes that in the Trika, this negation is a means, not an end: by negating identification with the inner faculties, one uncovers the pure consciousness that is their source.

2. विकल्पानामभावेन विकल्पैरुज्झितो भवेत् (vikalpānām abhāvena vikalpair ujjhito bhavet):

“Through the absence of thought-constructs, one becomes free from thought-constructs.”

  • विकल्पानाम् (vikalpānām) (gen. pl. m. of vikalpa): Of thought-constructs.
  • अभावेन (abhāvena) (abhāva ← √bhū; instr. sg. m.): Through the absence.
  • विकल्पैः (vikalpaiḥ) (instr. pl. m.): From thought-constructs.
  • उज्झितः (ujjhitaḥ) (√ujjh, 6P; p.p.p. ujjhita, nom. sg. m.): Free — abandoned, freed; past participle of √ujjh.
  • भवेत् (bhavet) (√bhū, 1P; opt. 3sg.): Becomes.

Interpretation (elaborative): Vikalpānām abhāvena, through the absence of thought-constructs: when the mind is negated, its products, the vikalpas, also have no basis. Then vikalpair ujjhito bhavet, one becomes freed from vikalpas. Ujjhita, abandoned, is a strong word: the vikalpas drop away like discarded objects. Kṣemarāja notes that this freedom is not a forcible suppression of thoughts but their natural cessation when their ground (the identification with the mind) is removed. Thoughts may still arise, but they no longer bind, because one no longer identifies with them. This is the state of nirvikalpa, central to the Tantra. For the practitioner, the dhāraṇā offers a quick, intellectual method of entering the thought-free state. It is particularly suited to those of a reflective temperament. After contemplating "I have no mind", rest in the awareness that remains. If thoughts arise, notice that they arise in awareness, not in "my mind", and let them pass. Over time, the identification with the mind weakens, and one abides as the pure, thought-free awareness that is Bhairava. Vikalpānām abhāvena, "through the absence of thought-constructs", which follows from the contemplation, the practitioner vikalpair ujjhito bhavet, "one becomes free from thought-constructs". The repetition is deliberate: first thoughts cease, then one is freed from them permanently. Kṣemarāja explains that when the mind is recognised as not one's self, its products, the vikalpas, lose their hold; one may still think, but one is no longer bound by thought. Ujjhita, "abandoned, freed", suggests a decisive release. The practitioner may experience this as a deep relief, a sense that the incessant chatter of the mind has lost its authority. Thoughts may continue to arise, but they are seen as passing clouds in the sky of awareness, no longer mistaken for the self.

Practice Guide

Practice Guide — Dhāraṇā 71 (verse 94)

Preparation & Posture

Sit upright with the eyes closed, in a quiet place. This is a contemplation through understanding (a śāmbhava or jñāna practice) rather than a technique of breath or body. The verse asks you to contemplate: "In me there is no inner faculty such as mind (citta)". Read the verse and its explanation beforehand. Breathe naturally and let the body become still for a few minutes.

Step-by-Step Method

1. Notice the activity of the mind: thoughts, images, plans and memories.

2. Notice that all of this activity appears in awareness and is known by it.

3. Ask quietly: is the awareness that knows the mind itself a "mind"?

4. Contemplate, as the verse says: "In me there is no inner faculty such as mind."

5. Let this contemplation be a recognition, not a denial: the mind appears, but you are not limited to it.

6. Each time a thought arises, recognise it as an appearance, not as yourself.

7. Rest in the awareness that remains when thoughts are not taken as "me".

8. Rest in the freedom from thought-constructs that follows, which the verse says makes one free; then open the eyes.

What to notice. At first, the contemplation may provoke more thinking; let it pass. Notice the moment when a thought is seen as an appearance rather than "me": it loses its grip. Notice the awareness that remains as quiet and spacious. Over time, notice thought becoming sparse and transparent.

Beginner variation: label thoughts as "thinking" for 10 minutes, and notice the awareness in which they appear.

Duration & Frequency

Beginners: 10–15 minutes. Established practitioners: 20–40 minutes, and as a recollection during the day.

Signs of Progress

Thoughts lose their grip; a sense of awareness independent of the mind; spaciousness; afterwards less identification with worries and opinions.

Common Mistakes

Trying to suppress thoughts; becoming argumentative with yourself; denying ordinary responsibility; becoming detached in a cold or dismissive way.

Cautions

A practice of understanding. If you feel unreal, detached or depersonalised, ground yourself in the body and in ordinary activity. Those with depersonalisation or dissociative conditions should practise with guidance.

Integration into Daily Life

When caught in a worry, notice it as a thought appearing in awareness.

Related dhāraṇās: compare Dhāraṇā 74 ("Who am I?", verse 97) and Dhāraṇā 84 (the mind without support, verse 108).

Traditional guidance, not medical advice; see “A Note on Safe Practice” in the Introduction.