Vijñāna Bhairava Tantra · Part III — The One Hundred and Twelve Dhāraṇās (Verses 24⁠–⁠138)

Dhāraṇā 102 — The unknowable, ungraspable, void — contemplated as Bhairava

Open in the interactive reader

यदवेद्यं यदग्राह्यं यच्छून्यं यदभावगम् । तत्सर्वं भैरवं भाव्यं तदन्ते बोधसम्भवः ॥ १२७ ॥
yad avedyaṃ yad agrāhyaṃ yac chūnyaṃ yad abhāvagam | tat sarvaṃ bhairavaṃ bhāvyaṃ tad-ante bodha-sambhavaḥ || 127 ||
PhoneticLine 1: yad | a-ved-yam | yad | ag-raah-yam | yach | chhoon-yam | yad | a-bhaa-va-gam Line 2: tat | sar-vam | bhai-ra-vam | bhaav-yam | tad-an-te | bo-dha-sam-bha-vah
“That which is unknowable, that which is ungraspable, that which is void, that which goes to non-existence — all that should be contemplated as Bhairava; at the end of that, illumination arises.”

Explanation

Dhāraṇā 102 is a contemplation of the unknowable. Whatever cannot be known (avedya), cannot be grasped (agrāhya), is void (śūnya), or belongs to non-existence (abhāva) — all this should be contemplated as Bhairava. At the end, bodha, awakening, arises. For the seeker, the verse turns the limits of knowledge into a doorway.

Detailed Explanation

1. यदवेद्यं यदग्राह्यं यच्छून्यं यदभावगम् (yad avedyaṃ yad agrāhyaṃ yac chūnyaṃ yad abhāvagam):

“That which is unknowable, that which is ungraspable, that which is void, that which goes to non-existence —”

  • यत् (yat) (relative pronoun, nom. sg. n.): That which.
  • अवेद्यम् (avedyam) (√vid, caus.; gerundive vedya negated; nom. sg. n.): Unknowable.
  • अग्राह्यम् (agrāhyam) (√grah, 9U; gerundive grāhya negated; nom. sg. n.): Ungraspable.
  • यत् शून्यम् (yat śūnyam) (yad + śūnya; nom. sg. n.): That which is void; यच्छून्यम् (t + ś → c + ch).
  • अभावगम् (abhāvagam) (upapada cpd. with -ga ← √gam; nom. sg. n.): That which goes to non-existence — pertaining to non-existence; abhāva + ga.

Interpretation (elaborative): Four categories of the "beyond" are named. Avedya, the unknowable: what cannot be an object of knowledge. Agrāhya, the ungraspable: what cannot be grasped by the senses or mind. Śūnya, the void: what is empty of all content. Abhāvaga, what pertains to non-existence: what seems not to exist at all. These are precisely the things the mind cannot handle; it turns away from them. Kṣemarāja explains that the mind usually dismisses the unknowable and the void as nothing; but in truth, they are the nature of the Supreme, which is beyond knowledge, beyond grasp, empty of objects. The Kena Upaniṣad (1.4–8) similarly says that Brahman is "that which the mind cannot think, but by which the mind is thought". For the practitioner: turn your attention to what you cannot know or grasp. What is beyond the edge of your awareness? What is the void between thoughts? What is non-existence? Do not try to understand these with the intellect; simply turn toward them with openness. Yad avedyam, "that which is unknowable", yad agrāhyam, "that which is ungraspable", yac chūnyam, "that which is void", yad abhāvagam, "that which goes to non-existence" (or "that which is accessible through non-being"). Śivopādhyāya explains that these describe what the mind cannot grasp: the unknowable, the ungraspable, the void, the non-existent. Ordinarily, the mind turns away from these, preferring the known and graspable. Kṣemarāja notes that the practice is to turn toward them. Each of them is a boundary of the mind, and at the boundary, consciousness beyond mind is glimpsed. In practice, one may contemplate what cannot be known — the source of thoughts, the space before birth, the moment after death — and rest in the not-knowing. This not-knowing is not ignorance but an openness beyond concepts.

2. तत्सर्वं भैरवं भाव्यं तदन्ते बोधसम्भवः (tat sarvaṃ bhairavaṃ bhāvyaṃ tad-ante bodha-sambhavaḥ):

“all that should be contemplated as Bhairava; at the end of that, illumination arises.”

  • तत् (tat) (nom. sg. n. of tad): That.
  • सर्वम् (sarvam) (nom. sg. n.): All.
  • भैरवम् (bhairavam) (adj. bhairava, nom. sg. n.): As Bhairava.
  • भाव्यम् (bhāvyam) (√bhū, caus.; gerundive bhāvya, nom. sg. n.): To be contemplated.
  • तदन्ते (tadante) (tatpuruṣa cpd.; loc. sg. m.): At the end of that.
  • बोधसम्भवः (bodhasambhavaḥ) (tatpuruṣa cpd.; bodha ← √budh; sambhava ← sam-√bhū; nom. sg. m.): Illumination arises — the arising of awakening; bodha + sambhava.

Interpretation (elaborative): Tat sarvaṃ bhairavaṃ bhāvyam: all that — the unknowable, ungraspable, void, non-existent — should be contemplated as Bhairava. This is a profound reversal: what the mind regards as nothing is revealed as the Supreme. Tad-ante bodha-sambhavaḥ: at the end of that contemplation, bodha, awakening or illumination, arises. Bodha is a key term in Kashmir Śaivism, meaning awakened consciousness, the light of the Self. Kṣemarāja explains that by contemplating the unknowable as Bhairava, the mind is drawn beyond its limits into the boundless consciousness, and there it awakens to its true nature. For the practitioner: this dhāraṇā can be practised when facing the unknown — uncertainty about the future, the mystery of death, the limits of understanding. Instead of fearing or avoiding the unknown, contemplate it as Bhairava. "This mystery is Bhairava. This void is Bhairava". This attitude transforms fear into wonder and leads to the awakening that is beyond all knowledge. Tat sarvaṃ bhairavaṃ bhāvyam, "all that should be contemplated as Bhairava", tad-ante bodha-sambhavaḥ, "at the end of that, illumination arises". Kṣemarāja explains that the unknowable, ungraspable, void and non-existent are not outside Bhairava; they are his transcendent aspect. By contemplating them as Bhairava, one transforms the mind's fear of the unknown into intimacy with the divine. Bodha-sambhava, "the arising of awakening", is the fruit. The practitioner may rest in the not-knowing, recognising it as Bhairava, until awakening dawns. This dhāraṇā invites the practitioner to embrace the mystery rather than trying to solve it. Abhinavagupta calls Bhairava anuttara, "the unsurpassable", that beyond which there is nothing; the unknowable is not a lack in him but the sign of his transcendence of every concept.

Practice Guide

Practice Guide — Dhāraṇā 102 (verse 127)

Preparation & Posture

Sit upright with the eyes closed, in a quiet place. The verse says that whatever is unknowable, ungraspable, void, or goes to non-existence, all that should be contemplated as Bhairava; at the end of that, illumination arises. This is a contemplation of the limits of knowing. Breathe naturally and let the body settle.

Step-by-Step Method

1. Notice what cannot be known: the moment before birth, what lies beyond the farthest stars, what you will think next.

2. Notice what cannot be grasped: the present moment, the flow of breath, awareness itself.

3. Notice what is void: the space between thoughts, the silence between sounds.

4. Notice what goes to non-existence: each thought, each sound, each moment as it passes.

5. Contemplate each of these not as a lack but as Bhairava.

6. Let the mind rest at the limits of knowing, without anxiety.

7. Remain there until the contemplation ends by itself.

8. At the end, notice the illumination (prakāśa) that the verse says arises.

What to notice. At first, the unknowable may feel frustrating or frightening. Notice that it is not empty but full of mystery. Notice the ungraspable present moment as alive. Notice the passing of things as a movement of awareness. Illumination often comes as a sudden, quiet clarity.

Beginner variation: watch sounds arising and passing for 10 minutes, contemplating their disappearance as Bhairava.

Duration & Frequency

Beginners: 10 minutes. Established practitioners: 20–30 minutes.

Signs of Progress

Ease with mystery; less anxiety about the unknown; clarity; afterwards wonder and openness.

Common Mistakes

Becoming anxious or depressed about non-existence; intellectualising; forcing illumination.

Cautions

Contemplating non-existence and the void can bring up fear or sadness. If so, open the eyes, ground yourself in the body and return to gentler practices. Those with depression should practise gently, with support.

Integration into Daily Life

When facing something unknown, rest for a breath in the open not-knowing.

Related dhāraṇās: compare Dhāraṇā 35 (the universe as void, verse 58) and Dhāraṇā 103 (external space, verse 128).

Traditional guidance, not medical advice; see “A Note on Safe Practice” in the Introduction.